Post-Holiday Sales Challenge: Turning One-Time Buyers into Repeat Customers

This case study explains how a multi-category online store uses an AI-driven solution to lower customer acquisition costs, boost conversion rates, and increase customer lifetime value after the busy fall holiday season. Even when organic traffic and sales drop by as much as 60-70%, the right strategies can keep your store growing.

Post-Holiday Sales Challenge: Turning One-Time Buyers into Repeat Customers

Let’s look at the fundamentals of a multi-category online store aiming to acquire new customers after the fall holiday season. After peak sales, most eCommerce stores experience drastic revenue dropdown - organic traffic and sales can be down as much as 60-70%

Connectors company logoTemplates block side image

The challenge is acquiring new customers without going net negative on profits.

Revenue Model Overview

Let’s break down the numbers for the store:

  • Average Order Value (AOV): The average purchase is $90.
  • Gross Margin: The store keeps 60% of each sale. This means that after a cost of $36, there’s $54 left from each order.
  • Marketing Budget: The store has $1,000 for marketing.
  • Cost Per Click: On average, each click costs $1.23.
  • Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): It costs about $41.67 to acquire a new customer.
  • Profit Runway per New Customer: After covering the acquisition cost, the store has about $12.33 left as profit or promotion budget for the first sale.

The challenge here is to profit on the very first sale to a new customer—even for those tough “comparison shoppers”—without going net negative.

Acquisition Strategies

To attract new customers, the store needs to keep costs low and improve conversion rates. Here’s how they approach this:

Cross/Up-Sell Tactics:

  • Use available data to suggest additional or upgraded products.
  • If detailed historical data isn’t available, the store might use the “Frequently bought together” strategy, although that sometimes isn’t enough to boost profits.

Retargeting Ads:

  • Show ads to visitors who didn’t convert the first time.
  • However, with a standard conversion rate of about 3%, you may need around 30 clicks (roughly $30) to make one conversion. This number is higher than the $12.33 profit margin available, so careful management of ad spend is critical.

Increasing Conversion Rates:

Discounts: Offering discounts can boost conversions, but it might also lower margins.

Personalization & Experimentation:

  • Tailor the user experience through targeted messaging and A/B testing.
  • For example, a 20% improvement in the conversion rate can increase profit per new customer from $12.33 to $19.52.
  • This extra profit can be reinvested in advertising or promotions, while still maintaining overall profitability.

Retention & Monetization

Acquiring a customer is just the beginning. To ensure long-term success, the store must focus on retaining customers and increasing their lifetime value (LTV).

LTV/CAC Ratio:

  • After the first purchase, the LTV is $90 compared to a CAC of $41.67, which gives a ratio of about 1:2.
  • To achieve a  CAC: LTV ratio of 1:3 or better, encouraging a repeat purchase is essential.

Post-Purchase Strategies:

  • Upselling: Offer complementary products or upgrades after the initial sale.

Personalized Offers: Engage customers with targeted offers that keep them connected to your brand and encourage repeat business.

Customer retention is vital because even the best acquisition efforts will not lead to long-term profitability if customers do not return.

Enter GrowthOS: The AI-Driven Solution

GrowthOS is an AI-powered platform that helps manage your entire customer lifecycle efficiently. It unifies customer data, predicts user intent using machine learning, and enables personalized marketing. This ensures that customers receive the right message at the right time.

How GrowthOS Helps

Data Integrations & Identity Resolution:

Connects various data sources to build a unified customer profile. This allows for a consistent experience and personalized interactions across all devices.

Timely Marketing Experiences:

Provides a suite of marketing tools that automate timely and personalized messages. This means you don’t have to rely on manual processes or juggling multiple spreadsheets.

Growth Methodology

GrowthOS is not just another tool - it is fundamentally a new way to operate your growth operations end-to-end.

We developed a thoroughly researched and industry-backed methodology to empower any business to level up its game in reaching the ultimate goal - growing faster & more profitably.

GrowthOS follows a clear, step-by-step approach:

Discover Audiences 🔮

Unify and analyze customer data from all channels and use machine learning to predict who is most likely to purchase

Discover: Identify, Build, and Analyze: Gather customer data from all your sources, combine it to form a complete picture, and use it to pinpoint your target leads and accounts.

Predict: Use machine learning to understand and forecast what your customers are likely to do next with real-time insights.

Engage Customers 💬

Personalize every interaction with automated triggers like emails or SMS based on real-time behavior.

Personalization: Tailor every communication across web, mobile, and email to suit individual customer needs and preferences.

Journeys: Based on real-time behavior, send timely emails or SMS when customers hit a new stage or show a drop in activity.

Optimize Experiences 💹

Experiment with different strategies and use insights to continually improve customer engagement.

Experiment: Test different strategies on your website or app with confidence and minimal risk to find what works best.

Analyze: Review the results of your experiments to gain clear, actionable insights that drive continuous improvement.

By using GrowthOS, businesses can simplify their operations and focus on growing revenue without the heavy burden of manual data management.

Final Thoughts & Takeaways

After the holiday rush, many online stores face a steep decline in organic traffic and sales. This case study demonstrates that by focusing on lowering acquisition costs, boosting conversion rates, and increasing customer lifetime value, you can successfully navigate the post-holiday slump.

Key Takeaways:

Focus on Lowering Costs & Boosting Conversions: Use data-driven strategies to reduce customer acquisition costs and improve free-to-paid conversion rates.

Leverage Automation for Personalization: Implement tools that unify customer data and automate timely, personalized interactions.

Prioritize Retention: Enhance customer lifetime value by encouraging repeat purchases through effective upselling and targeted post-purchase strategies.

Whether you rely on manual methods like spreadsheets and careful ad targeting or adopt an automated solution like GrowthOS, the key is to use data-driven insights to make smarter decisions. With the right strategies in place, even a challenging post-holiday season can turn into an opportunity for growth and higher profits. Happy scaling!

BTW, If you have Intempt in mind then, we created a library of growbooks to get inspiration on starting up with Intempt on the fly.

Good to Know
  • AOV (Average Order Value): The average amount each customer spends per purchase.
  • Gross Margin: The percentage of revenue that remains after deducting the direct cost of the product or service.
  • CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost): The total cost of acquiring a new customer, including marketing and advertising expenses.
  • Profit Runway: The profit remaining after covering the cost to acquire a customer, which can be reinvested or used for promotions.
  • LTV (Lifetime Value): The total revenue a business can expect from a single customer over the entire duration of their relationship.
  • LTV/CAC Ratio: A measure of how much value a customer brings compared to the cost of acquiring them. A higher ratio indicates a more profitable customer.
Thanks for reading till the end. Here are 3 ways we can help you grow your business:
1.Boost growth with proven growbooks: Explore our GrowthBook Library, filled with actionable growth tactics and step-by-step guides to unlock your app's potential.
Check out Growth Book Library ➡️
2. Create a free GrowthOS account: Create a free GrowthOS account and get started on the journey to grow your app.
Get started free on GrowthOS ➡️
3. Get advice from a Growth expert: Schedule a personalized discovery call with our founder to explore how GrowthOS can help you grow your business.
Book a growth call ➡️
Subscribe to AI Powered Growth
Get our newest insights for Growth practitioners
You did it! 🥳 Keep an eye on your email
for new content from us!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Looking for ways to grow faster?

Discover marketing workspace where you turn audiences into revenue.

Learn about Intempt

You might also like...

Ultimate Guide to Reducing Churn with AI-Powered User Retention Strategies
Retain App Users

Ultimate Guide to Reducing Churn with AI-Powered User Retention Strategies

Your app is doing well, with users actively exploring features and making regular purchases. But then you start noticing subtle changes. A previously engaged user logs in less frequently. Their in-app purchases decrease. They interact with fewer features each week. Despite being a loyal subscriber for months, their engagement gradually fades until they finally cancel their subscription altogether. Sound familiar?

read more
Right blue arrow
How AI can stop cart abandonment before it happens
Test & Personalize CX

How AI can stop cart abandonment before it happens

Cart abandonment has long been one of the most persistent challenges in e-commerce. Most businesses have tried to tackle it with reactive approaches like post-abandonment emails and SMS or a retargeting ad campaign. However, these methods often reach customers with “too little, too late,” - they’ve already moved on.

read more
Right blue arrow
How to Boost Conversions & Lower Costs with Personalized Landing Pages
Increase Order Value

How to Boost Conversions & Lower Costs with Personalized Landing Pages

Imagine your customers landing on a page that feels generic and out-of-touch—whether it's during a product launch, customer onboarding, or a seasonal promotion. That initial disconnect not only wastes your budget but also leaves your visitors feeling like just another number.

read more
Right blue arrow

Subscribe to AI Powered Growth  🔐

Get our newest insights for Growth practitioners

You did it! 🥳 Keep an eye on your email
for new content from us!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Note remove icon

Web A/B testing

Use front-end A/B and multi-page experimentation product built for any business size. Run multiple experiments on the same page.

GPS icon

Targeting & personalization

Deliver targeted messaging, personalized offers and recommend the most relevant content for your users.

Edit icon

Visual editor

Empower your team to collaborate with an easy-to-use visual editor without using developer time to get things up and running.

Presentation chart icon

Analytics

Gain insight into the impact of your experiments with statistically valid results. No complex statistical analysis required.

Search icon

Server & client-side testing

Go beyond client-side testing and deploy experiments on the server-side. Test and optimize content changes and even complete re-brands.

Shuffle icon

Flexible goal selection

Select the right goal for each personalization and experimentation campaign to ensure you’re optimizing towards the right objectives.